<요약> ·················································································································1

Ⅰ. 서론 ···············································································································1

1. 연구 필요성 및 목적 ························································································1

2. 주요 요구 사항 ································································································2

Ⅱ. 국방연구개발에 대한 일반적 고찰 ······················································3

1. 연구개발의 정의 및 분류 ················································································3

가. 연구개발의 정의 ·························································································3

나. 연구개발의 분류 ·························································································3

2. 연구개발의 특징 및 관리원칙 ········································································7

3. 국방연구개발 수행절차 ··················································································11

가. 소요결정 ·····································································································11

나. 무기체계 연구개발 ···················································································12

다. 핵심기술 연구개발 ···················································································14

4. 국방연구개발과 타 정부부처 연구개발 간의 차이 ··································14

Ⅲ. 국방연구개발의 실패사례 분석 및 시사점 ······································17

1. 연구개발에 있어서 실패의 의미 ································································17

2. 국방연구개발에서 실패의 개념 및 원인 ····················································22

3. 국방연구개발 실패사례 분석 ········································································24

가. 국내 사례 ···································································································24

1) 유무선 전자식 전술교환기(SB 30-K) ················································24

2) 군단 UAV ······························································································25

3) 신궁 야간조준기···················································································27

4) UH-60시뮬레이터 ··················································································29

나. 해외 사례 ···································································································30

1) A-12 어벤저II 개발사업 ······································································30

2) MBT70 전차 ···························································································32

3) RAH-66 코만치 헬기···········································································34

4) X-32 수직이착륙 전투기·····································································36

5) 아준 전차·······························································································37

4. 시사점: 실패에 대한 대응 방안 ·······························································40

Ⅳ. 국내외 연구개발 실패 최소화를 위한 법제 분석 ·························45

1. 방위사업법령 검토의 범위 ··········································································45

2. 방위사업법령의 특성 ······················································································46

가. 국가계약법 원리의 원칙적 도입 ···························································46

나. 과학기술기본법 원리의 부분적 도입 ···················································56

3. 방위사업법령상 국방연구개발사업과 실패 ················································61

4. 국내외의 연구개발 실패 최소화를 위한 법제 분석 ································64

가. 법제 분석의 필요성 ·················································································64

나. 법제 분석의 범위 및 대상 ·····································································64

1) 법제 분석의 범위 ·················································································64

2) 법제 분석의 대상 ·················································································64

다. 주요 연구개발 법제 비교분석 ·······························································65

1) 연구개발 결과평가 법제 ·····································································65

2) 연구개발 실패 최소화(성공률 향상)를 위한 법제 ·························95

3) 연구개발 실패에 대한 제재 법제 ···················································113

4) 연구 개발 실패지식의 활용 법제 ···················································131

Ⅴ. 국방연구개발사업 실패 최소화를 위한 개선방안 ·······················137

1. 평가위원 후보단(DB) 구성 ·········································································137

2. 시험 평가 위원구성 기준 마련 ··································································139

3. 연구노트 작성?관리의무 부과 ··································································141

4. 실패개념의 도입 ····························································································142

5. 실패에 대한 제재수단 마련 ········································································144

6. 성실실패의 판정기준 마련 ··········································································153

7. 실패원인 보고서 작성의무 부과 ································································154

8. 실패과제 정보(지식) DB 구축 ···································································157

9. 국방 연구개발 단계별 성공률 향상 ························································159

10. 집행중 성과분석 제도 설치 ······································································160

Ⅵ. 결론 ·········································································································163

1. 실패사례 분석을 통한 대응방안 모색 ····················································163

2. 법제 분석을 통한 대응방안 모색 ··························································164

가. 국방 연구개발 관련 규정의 현황 ·····················································164

나. 개선 방안 ·······························································································166

3. 맺음말 ············································································································169

<참고문헌> ·····································································································171